
Benton County election officials just revealed in a press release that a small fiber that was lodged inside a ballot-counting machine contributed to more than 2,000 overvotes in the November 3rd election.
In the release, Benton County Clerk Darla Rush provided a behind-the-scenes account of the process of counting, verifying, and certifying the results.
(Photo: Benton County Elections)
Election officials noted a discrepancy when workers conducted manual counts of ballot batches and then compared them with the machine’s results. While single-choice contests matched up in the audit, votes in ranked-choice races had incorrectly been classified as overvotes rather than assigned to a candidate.
Rush then contacted Election Systems & Software, the company responsible for the equipment. After several tests, officials discovered a fiber lodged in one of the machine’s feeding wheels.
The machine is sensitive enough to interpret anything inside a ballot’s voting oval as a selection, including stray marks or debris.
After removing the fiber, election workers ran every ballot through the machine again. The number of reported overvotes dropped from more than 2,000 to just 77, according to the release.
Did you know that on November 12th, Benton County updated the election results with thousands of additional votes from the initial results reported on November 3rd?
No, this wasn’t due to the thread. But we were surprised these updated results were not reported on.
The additional votes came from ballots postmarked by Election Day but delivered afterward, ballots deposited in other Oregon counties, and ballots requiring additional processing.
There are still two contests that have gone to ranked-choice voting without a winner confirmed yet.
In the mayoral race, the first-choice totals showed Mayor Charles Maughan expanding his lead over challenger Andrew Struthers.
Maughan gained 1,001 votes in this November 12th update, while Struthers gained 853. This gave Maughan an even larger buffer when ranked-choice votes are tallied and posted.
But mathematically speaking, Struthers still has a chance.
In Ward 7, Jerry Ingersoll gained 135 votes, while Danielle Chambers added 159, reducing Ingersoll’s advantage from 54 to just 30 votes. To make it more interesting, Asa Jorg gained 26 votes. Asa now has 133 votes that will go to Ingersoll or Chambers in ranked-choice voting.
The county’s press release and the new vote totals are a good illustration of why election-night results are preliminary.
“The voter’s role in the election is done at that point, but there are still weeks of work ahead for my team to process, tabulate, and provide results that can be certified,” Rush said.
The next unofficial results are scheduled for November 25th, when the mayoral race and Ward 7 should be updated with the final ranked-choice voting.
This article was written by Jesse Grant, a contributor at The Corvallis Inquirer. Feel free to send us your stories or articles to publish at: editor@corvallisnow.com
More recent stories:


→ Donate
We’ll still keep it ad-free and paywall-free even if you don’t. 100% of donations go to expanding local reporting, giving back to community causes, and minor operating expenses. Read more about our values and mission here.

Do you have a story for The Inquirer? Email us. We respond: editor@corvallisnow.com









